Chicken and Mushroom Pie

Today, we will be preparing a Chicken and Mushroom Pie, loved in many parts of the world, and known for its golden-brown crust that encases earthy mushrooms alongside tender pieces of chicken, this hearty meal has a special place in the hearts of millions of people.

During the Medieval period in England, pie crusts were composed primarily of flour and water, the purpose of pie crusts was to serve as a means of food preservation, rendering the crust itself inedible.

However, by the 16th century, the formulation of pie crusts had evolved significantly, transitioning from a robust dense structure to a lighter, flakier, and more buttery composition. Notably, the Ancient Egyptians are recognized as pioneers in the development of pie crusts, utilizing oats, wheat, and barley. Interestingly, a recipe for chicken pie was inscribed on a tablet that dates back to 2000 BC. This indicates that the first recorded mention of chicken pie occurred over 4,000 years ago.

Ingredients

Chicken breasts or thighs, Salt, Black pepper, Paprika, Oregano, Thyme, Shortcut pastry, Puff pastry, Fresh cream, Dijon mustard, Butter, Egg , Flour, Beans. Onions, Mushroom, Garlic cloves, Green onions, Fresh Parsley.

Chicken breasts and thighs are suitable for making chicken and mushroom pie. Breasts are lean and tender, while thighs are juicier and richer in flavor due to higher fat content. Cutting the chicken uniformly promotes even cooking. Essential seasonings include salt for overall flavor, black pepper for earthiness, paprika for a smoky note, oregano for a citrusy touch, and thyme for minty undertones.

Shortcut pastry creates a crumbly base for the pie. Blind baking prevents the pastry from rising into odd shapes. Puff pastry forms the flaky top, brushed with egg for a glossy finish. Fresh cream adds a smooth, luxurious texture, Dijon mustard provides a spicy kick, and butter enriches the filling, while flour thickens the gravy for a cohesive, creamy mixture.

During the blind-baking phase, beans add weight to the shortcrust pastry, helping it retain its shape, while onions add sweetness and depth of flavor. Mushrooms enhance the dish’s savory quality, and fresh parsley adds a vibrant herbaceous note. Garlic cloves add an aromatic, slightly spicy dimension, and green onions offer a mild and fresh taste, further elevating the dish’s flavor profile.

---

What makes a Great Chicken & Mushroom pie?

Chicken and mushroom pie features chicken, vegetables, and a flavorful gravy that brings everything together. Fresh herbs, Dijon mustard, and cream enhance the sauce’s texture and taste. The pie can be made as a pot pie, hand pie, or English pie, typically using two types of dough: a shortcrust base and puff pastry topping. If you skip the shortcrust and use only puff pastry, it becomes a Chicken and Mushroom pot pie.

Instructions

Remove the store-bought shortcrust and puff pastry from the freezer and let them sit for about thirty minutes to reach room temperature. Roll out the shortcrust pastry to line a casserole dish, pressing it into the corners. To prevent shrinking while baking, blind-bake it by lining the surface with parchment paper and adding baking beans.

Preheat the oven to 190 °C and bake the casserole for 10 to 15 minutes. Remove it from the oven, take off the parchment paper and beans, then return it to bake for another 10 minutes, until the pastry is lightly golden. Blind baking prevents shrinkage and ensures an even bake.

In a large pan, add two tablespoons of olive oil and the minced garlic cloves. Sauté for 7 to 9 minutes, until the garlic is caramelized, which adds depth to the chicken and mushroom pie.

Cook the chicken for 5–8 minutes, stirring frequently for flavor. Add the sliced spring onions and mushrooms, then mix in fresh cream, spices, and Dijon mustard. Let it simmer on low for 7–9 minutes, stirring occasionally to avoid burning.

Transfer the filling to the casserole dish with the shortcrust pastry, spreading it evenly. Cover it with puff pastry, sealing the filling inside.

Separate one egg into a small bowl and whisk it. Brush the egg wash on the puff pastry. Bake the chicken and mushroom pie for twenty to twenty-five minutes until golden brown, then let it rest for ten minutes.

Chicken and mushroom pie is popular in the UK and the US, where many enjoy pot pies without the bottom shortcrust pastry for a quicker option. In Australia, mashed potatoes and peas make it heartier, while the French enhance theirs with wine and salami.

How to store Chicken and Mushroom Pie?

Store in the fridge for two to three days. Reheat in the microwave. Freeze the pie for two to three months. Use disposable foil tins for the pie. Pre-bake the shortcrust pastry and add the filling. Top with the puff pastry and freeze. Only bake the pies when it is time to eat them.

What can you serve with Chicken and Mushroom Pie?

Serve alongside a Simple green salad or Caesar salad. Other side dishes include mashed potatoes and roasted vegetables. Consider this Green bean recipe if you want a side dish with unique flavours. It will pair well with the Chicken and mushroom pie.